Role of cytoreductive nephrectomy (CN) in metastatic clear cell renal cell carcinoma (mccRCC) in the era of immunotherapy (IO): An analysis of the National Cancer Database (NCDB).

Authors

Maroun Bou Zerdan

Maroun Bou Zerdan

SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY

Maroun Bou Zerdan , Roger Wong , Hanan Goldberg , Alina Basnet

Organizations

SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, Department of Public Health & Preventive Medicine, College of Medicine, SUNY Upstate, Syracuse, NY

Research Funding

No funding received
None.

Background: The role of CN remains questionable after the well intentioned two large prospective trials, SURTIME AND CARMENA, failed to show the benefit of CN for mccRCC, with Sunitinib as standard of care. Methods: We identified stage IV mccRCC only patients (pts) who received IO with or without surgery in the NCDB 2004-2018. Overall survival (OS) was calculated among three groups of IO alone (group (gr)1), IO followed by CN (gr2), CN followed by IO (gr3). Cox models compared OS by treatment group after adjusting for sociodemographic, health, and facility variables. Results: From 615,519 renal cancer cases, 2,903 met our criteria. 6.96% of ccRCC had sarcomatoid histology. Pts in the gr 2 and gr 3 had 63%, 95% CI [0.265-0.510] and 46%, 95% CI [0.487- 0.594], P= 0.001, risk reduction in mortality compared to IO alone. Black race compared to white race, education attainment quartile < 6.3% compared to > 17.6%, uninsured pts compared to privately insured, and pts treated at community cancer center compared to academic center had an increased mortality risk by 16%, 95% CI [0.980-1.387] (P= 0.083), 26%, 95% CI [1.054-1.511] (P= 0.011), 30%, 95% CI [1.003-1.683] (P= 0.047), 44%, 95% CI [1.161-1.779] (P= 0.001) respectively. Median income quartiles ranging > 63k, had 25% reduction in mortality over income quartiles < 40k, 95% CI [0.630-0.902] (P= 0.002). Regardless of the sequence of CN, partial nephrectomy was minimally used. Pts with brain and liver metastasis had a 48% (P= 0.063) and a 79% (P= 0.001) chance of increased risk of mortality. Conclusions: Pts receiving CN regardless of sequence with IO did better than IO alone in this national registry-based adjusted analysis for mccRCC. International Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma Database Consortium risk stratification of pts was not done however Charlson-Deyo Comorbidity Index, visceral/brain metastasis were accounted for in OS analysis. Limitations inherited in the retrospective nature of this study are lack of randomization and pts’ and physicians’ choice. We believe the role of CN does warrant prospective validation in the era of IO for stage IV ccRCC. OS at 2 and 5 yrs for all three groups, with respective 95% CI.

IO (%) 95% CIIOCN (%) 95% CICNIO (%) 95% CI
2 YRS FOLLOW-UP29.88 [27.56-32.23]70 [60.62-78.67]55 [52.38-57.54]
5 YRS FOLLOW-UP10.74 [8.63-13.11]37.60 [25.33-49.82]30.47 [27.78-33.20]

Disclaimer

This material on this page is ©2024 American Society of Clinical Oncology, all rights reserved. Licensing available upon request. For more information, please contact licensing@asco.org

Abstract Details

Meeting

2023 ASCO Annual Meeting

Session Type

Poster Session

Session Title

Genitourinary Cancer—Kidney and Bladder

Track

Genitourinary Cancer—Kidney and Bladder

Sub Track

Kidney Cancer

Citation

J Clin Oncol 41, 2023 (suppl 16; abstr 4552)

DOI

10.1200/JCO.2023.41.16_suppl.4552

Abstract #

4552

Poster Bd #

44

Abstract Disclosures

Similar Abstracts

First Author: Takefumi Komiya

First Author: Nir Horesh

First Author: Edward Christopher Dee