Background: Treatment-free survival (TFS) with and without (w/o) toxicity are outcome measures that describe health states where patients are experiencing clinically stable disease while off anti-cancer treatment, a clinically meaningful attribute seen with some immune-oncology (IO) regimens. We sought to characterize TFS with and w/o ongoing toxicity in addition to time on protocol therapy (combination and monotherapy) in trials of frontline IO-VEGF tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) combinations in pts with advanced renal cell carcinoma (aRCC). Methods: We pooled randomized trials submitted to FDA evaluating IO-TKI combination in treatment-naïve aRCC with at least 30 months (mos) of median follow-up. OS was partitioned into health states, including TFS, defined as area between Kaplan-Meier curves for 2 time-to-event endpoints originating at randomization: 1) time to all protocol therapy cessation and 2) time to subsequent systemic therapy initiation or death. Health state areas under the curve were estimated by 30-mo restricted mean times. We pooled data by treatment arm. Results: Three trials (KEYNOTE-426, JAVELIN Renal 100, CheckMate 9ER) met criteria for analysis; in total, 1183 pts received IO-TKI vs. 1184 on control arms receiving sunitinib (SUN). IO-TKI and SUN groups spent 9% (2.7 mos [95% confidence interval (CI): 1.8, 3.5]) and 10% (2.9 mos [95% CI: 2.1, 3.8]) of the 30-mo period alive and treatment-free. Mean TFS with grade ≥3 toxicity were 1 and 0.6 mos in the IO-TKI and SUN groups, respectively. Mean TFS w/o grade ≥3 toxicity were 1.7 and 2.3 mos in IO-TKI and SUN groups, respectively. In IO-TKI group, the 30-mo mean time on combination therapy was 13.7 mos (46% of 30-mo period) and 3.9 mos on monotherapy (13% of 30-mo period). Following cessation of one drug in IO-TKI arm, monotherapy duration of TKI was longer than IO: 2.9 and 1 mos, respectively. Conclusions: In this descriptive, exploratory analysis, TFS and TFS w/o toxicity were similar in IO-TKI group compared to SUN group, in contrast to improved TFS in IO-IO vs. SUN seen in published literature. Among pts on IO-TKI, more time was spent on TKI monotherapy than IO monotherapy. These findings may reflect continuation of TKI until progression per protocol design in all trials and discontinuation of IO after 2 years in 2 trials, and may inform individual pt choice of IO-IO vs. IO-TKI.