Background: DPD deficiency is a pharmacogenetic syndrome associated with dose-limiting toxicity to fluoropyrimidines. Oncologists are expected to recognize and diagnose this syndrome, as toxicities could be fatal. Over 40 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and deletions have been identified within the DPYD gene. IVS14+1G>A (DPYD*2A) is the most common (40-50%) and best studied of these SNPs. Yet, it showed a median sensitivity of 30% and is absent in Japanese, Korean and African Americans. Overall, the data on DPYD testing is insufficient to provide enough guidance to diagnose DPD deficiency. Herein we describe our experience with germline pharmacogenomics in patients with DPD deficiency. Methods: Between 2011 and 2015, 35 patients with gastrointestinal malignancies were tested for DPYD mutations; 17 were tested after developing toxicities to treatment and 18 were tested prior to treatment. IVS14+1G>A (DPYD*2A) was tested in all patients. DPYD c.85T>C (DPYD*9A), DPYD c.1679T>G (DPYD*13A), DPYD c.-1590T>C, and DPYD c.2846A>T were tested in 24 patients (69%) only. We explored the association between DPYD mutations and fluoropyrimidine-related toxicity using Fisher’s exact test. Results: Median age was 60 years, 43% were male, 80% were Caucasian and 20% were African American. Capecitabine-based regimens (71%) and 5-Fluorouracil-based regimens (29%). 14 out of 35 patients (40%) had DPYD mutations. Grade 3 toxicities were encountered in 64% of patients with DPYD mutation and 48% of patients with no DPYD mutation. In patients who received full dose fluoropyrimidines (57% of patients with DPYD mutation and 81% of patients with no DPYD mutation), DPYD mutations were associated with a significantly higher rate of grade 3 diarrhea (p=0.026). In patients with DPYD mutation, 2 (14%) had DPYD*A2 mutation and 12 (86%) had DPYD*9A mutation. Conclusions: In patients treated with fluoropyrimidines, the rate of grade 3 diarrhea was significantly higher in patients with mutated DPYD gene. Testing for DPYD*2A alone to diagnose DPD deficiency is suboptimal. Testing for other DPYD mutation variants including DPYD*9A provides a more comprehensive approach. These data should further be validated in prospective clinical trials.