Analysis of stage of melanoma diagnosis in relation to insurance type and income as indicator of early/late diagnosis.

Authors

null

Peter Makram Lamie

Creighton University, Omaha, NE

Organizations

Creighton University, Omaha, NE

Research Funding

No funding sources reported

Background: This study compares the average stage of diagnosis for melanoma by insurance status and household income. This is the largest such study for melanoma to date. Methods: Using the National Cancer Database we examined 299K patients with melanoma between 2000 and 2009 at 1,408 hospitals. The relationship of average stage of diagnosis is compared across insurance types and by income for 293K patients. Results: The VA patients had the lowest average stage of diagnosis 0.8 with the Medicaid population exhibiting the highest 1.8. The VA was lower than Tricare which had an average diagnosis of 1.1, private insurance 1.2, Medicare 1.3, and uninsured 1.7. The lowest rate of stage IV was private insurance 3.3%, Tricare 3.6%, VAH 4.4%, Medicare 5.7%, uninsured 10%, and the highest rate was among Medicaid 14.3%. The highest income category ≥$49K had the lowest average stage at diagnosis of 1.1 compared to $39K to $48K 1.2, $33K to $38K 1.3, $28K to $32K 1.4, and <$28K had the highest average stage of diagnosis 1.4. Stage IV rate increased from the highest income 3.6%, $39K to $48K 4.6%, $33K to $38K 5.1%, $28K to $32K 5.8%, and <$28K 6.9%. Data available. Conclusions: VA, higher income and private insurance had earlier stage of melanoma compared to uninsured and Medicaid who had higher frequency of stage IV disease.

Insurance type Stage
Weighted average
Stage of diagnosis
P value of
average stage of
diagnosis
Totals
0 I II III IV N %
Veterans affairs 3,758 3,068 823 422 377 0.89 8,448 2.82%
44.48% 36.32% 9.74% 5.00% 4.46% 100%
Tricare/military 1,017 1,813 401 309 135 1.11 <0.0001 3675 1.23%
27.67% 49.33% 10.91% 8.41% 3.67% 100%
Private insurance 36,952 89,811 21,346 16,183 5,623 1.20 <0.0001 16,9915 56.79%
21.75% 52.86% 12.56% 9.52% 3.31% 100%
Medicare 24,312 42,255 21,025 10,308 5,965 1.34 <0.0001 103,865 34.71%
23.41% 40.68% 20.24% 9.92% 5.74% 100%
Uninsured 952 3080 1324 1290 748 1.70 <0.0001 7,394 2.47%
12.88% 41.66% 17.91% 17.45% 10.12% 100%
Medicaid 751 2,161 946 1,210 849 1.87 <0.0001 5,917 1.98%
12.69% 36.52% 15.99% 20.45% 14.35% 100%
Total 67,742 142,188 45,865 29,722 13,697 299,214 100.00%
22.64% 47.52% 15.33% 9.93% 4.58% 100%

P value based on student t-statistic calculated for weighted average stage of diagnosis. VA is the comparison category.

Disclaimer

This material on this page is ©2024 American Society of Clinical Oncology, all rights reserved. Licensing available upon request. For more information, please contact licensing@asco.org

Abstract Details

Meeting

2013 ASCO Annual Meeting

Session Type

Poster Session

Session Title

Melanoma/Skin Cancers

Track

Melanoma/Skin Cancers

Sub Track

Melanoma/Skin Cancers

Citation

J Clin Oncol 31, 2013 (suppl; abstr 9099)

DOI

10.1200/jco.2013.31.15_suppl.9099

Abstract #

9099

Poster Bd #

53D

Abstract Disclosures

Similar Abstracts

First Author: Alec Czaplicki

First Author: Siran M. Koroukian

First Author: Peter Lamie

First Author: Elyse Xinyue Zhang